gnome settings audit
Candidate: main 44edb6aca704ef0ada32b8c6111383ea5c3c6afe, 2026-10-06. Reference: GNOME control-center 51.0, with panel C, Blueprint and GtkBuilder sources inspected. The static item catalog retains source locations; the 429-key desktop inventory is a separate input. Dynamic devices, apps, permissions and shortcuts require runtime enumeration. Neither inventory is a behavior pass.
Merged follow-ups through main 95490e3 add finite bounded Activities triggers (#369), GNOME enum reduced-motion handling (#370), truthful rejection of unsupported display mode/disable requests (#371), and strict native VM lifecycle qualification (#265). The source-pinned catalog remains the original audit input; those fixes do not close their broader capability or published-image acceptance issues.
Follow-up source review: main c822ab91abbb8c07fdd89ddde5c81a71f7843ff3, 2026-10-06. The original pinned catalog remains the audit input. Qualified merges add live calendar weekday/week-number preferences (#381), logical output-aware LTR corners (#386), and mouse/touchpad handedness with lock keyboard-state/focus repairs (#379). These cover parts of the corresponding issues; their remaining requirements stay open.
The desktop does not yet work fully with GNOME Settings. Some controls work live, some only store preferences, some have no consumer, and service-backed controls lack shipped-image acceptance. Nested tests do not certify physical peripherals, multi-output GPU behavior or the final image.
Status: live means a source consumer exists (test scope is given in settings-map); missing/partial means a confirmed implementation limitation; qualify means an external service or runtime path requires evidence, not that the service is known absent.
Central GitHub tracker contains all capability and existing production acceptance issues.
Qualification update: 2026-10-07
Current merged source: a87f1d681e38975f29521f342c0fa4d565c345ff. The panel catalog above remains pinned to GNOME 51. This update records reviewed behavior and its limits; it does not mark an entire panel or application complete.
- Hot corners: #444 qualifies stock GNOME Settings overview modes and restart, #445 adds native relative-motion pressure and held/leave/rearm/disable controls, and #455 implements region-aware pointer constraints and layer origins. The fresh native #455 run retains one original layer client, 111 observations, 33 relative and 11 absolute controls, active lock/confine suppression, empty-region deactivation, persistent reactivation, and positives after destruction. Five pristine boots include ONE complete lifecycle. #449 remains open for native holes, input-region intersections, one-shot constraints and other geometry; #336 additionally requires RTL, native fractional-scale/multi-output, physical and shipped-image qualification.
- Authentication and privacy: the fresh #455 GTK run passes 155 assertions and 24 scale assertions at 1, 1.25, 1.5 and 2. These include real PAM rejection/acceptance, exactly one first printable password character, fullscreen corner guards, and omitted locked pointer/keyboard diagnostics. This does not qualify native fractional-scale constraints or interactive authentication beyond one password (#366).
- Accessibility: AT-SPI exposes GTK shell controls and supports the test harness, but this does not establish spoken shell navigation. Merged #446 qualifies distribution Orca activation, restart and logout in its native scope. Candidate #453 is still under validation: its
4a29fceOrca 51 run passes native keyboard commands, real PAM and held-key privacy, then fails final disable. Its paired PCM includes multiple streams and does not prove exclusive speech origin. The subsequent stop-request fix requires fresh complete evidence. #352 remains open. - Backgrounds and alerts: #447, #454, #458 and #459 remain candidates. Passing older candidate receipts do not establish the current heads. Generated Fontconfig-cache provenance, actual SVG behavior, audible PCM, and fresh complete image/VM checks remain under review. Broad #360, #452 and #353 remain open.
Panel controls and responsible paths
| Panel | Controls / behavior | Current mapping | Tracking |
|---|---|---|---|
| Appearance / Background | Default/dark style, accent, add/select picture; placement and dynamic backgrounds | Style/accent via GTK, wallpaper URIs live; placement/dynamic metadata partial | #360 |
| Displays | Scale, arrangement, primary; resolution, refresh/VRR, join/mirror, orientation, enable/disable, HDR, adjust for TV | Scale/position/primary live; modes/rotation/mirror partial; HDR/color missing; VRR/TV qualification | #340, #341, #345, #364 |
| Night Light | Enable, restart filter, schedule, from/to, temperature | Stored only; capability false; no color transform | #339 |
| Mouse & Touchpad | Left/right primary, mouse speed/acceleration/natural scroll; touchpad enable, typing/mouse disable, click method, tap, speed, scroll method/direction; pointing stick | The keys Mutter 51's input settings apply reach libinput live and on hotplug with its per-device-class rules, including touchpad send-events (disabled while a mouse is plugged), click method, two-finger/edge scrolling, tap options, middle-click and scroll-wheel emulation and pointing-stick speed/scroll method; USB-mouse hotplug re-apply proven by V-POINTER-HOTPLUG and mouse options by V-POINTER-LIVE; custom acceleration curves, the typing-disable timeout and sticky drag lock are unsupported by the pinned libinput bindings, touchpad scroll-speed is unread, and physical touchpad, trackball and pointing-stick qualification remain | #343 |
| Keyboard | Add/reorder/remove input source; shared/per-window, alternate/compose key; repeat; overview and custom/default shortcuts | Sources/options/repeat and many shell grabs live; per-window/Num Lock/custom service and remaining actions incomplete | #346, #347 |
| Multitasking | Hot corner, edge resize, dynamic/fixed/count, primary/all-display workspaces, app-switch inclusion; reopen windows | Corner policy, bounds, logical output origins, LTR eligibility and native pressure/held/rearm behavior are merged; scoped native persistent constraint behavior and GTK fullscreen guards are qualified above; RTL, broader native geometry/scaling, hardware and shipped-image acceptance remain; other policies remain incomplete. "Reopen Windows After Login" is hidden as in GNOME 51 (RestoreSupported false); opt-in window restoration through xdg_session_manager_v1 is nested-proven (P-SY-08), installed logout/reboot qualification remains | #336, #337, #338 |
| Notifications | DND, global lock notifications, per-app enable/sound/banner/details/lock/details | Global DND live; per-app and lock privacy preferences ignored | #348 |
| Accessibility: Seeing | Reader/configuration, contrast, status shapes, motion, text/cursor size, sound keys, scrollbars, focus visibility | Some GTK keys and GNOME reduced-motion enum / shell animation control work; compositor cursor and modern preferences missing; spoken reader unqualified | #342, #351, #352 |
| Accessibility: Hearing | Overamplification, visual alerts, flash area/test | Native overamplification, volume feedback and audible/visual bell consumers exist; physical audio and visual pixel qualification remain pending | #353 |
| Accessibility: Typing | Screen keyboard, keyboard enable shortcuts, caret blink/speed, repeat/delay, sticky/slow/bounce keys and beeps | GTK caret and native repeat subset; screen keyboard and seat aids missing | #349, #350 |
| Accessibility: Pointing & Clicking | Mouse Keys, locate pointer, hover focus, double-click delay, simulated secondary and hover click | Toolkit double-click translation separate from compositor; seat aids and hover policy missing | #342, #347, #350 |
| Accessibility: Zoom | Enable, factor/lens/screen/follow, extend edges, crosshair color/size/overlap, inversion/brightness/contrast/color | No compositor magnifier | #349 |
| Wellbeing | History enable, daily limit, grayscale, eyesight/movement reminders/schedule/sounds | No policy/history/reminder consumers | #354 |
| Power | Power mode/button, charge max/health, battery percentage, ambient/dim/blank, automatic saver/suspend battery/AC/delay | Percentage and native backlight live; org.gnome.Shell.Brightness exported (controlled fixture) and DisplayConfig PowerSaveMode blanks/unblanks with Mutter 51 semantics (nested proof); no session gnome-settings-daemon power plugin consumes dim/blank/suspend; hardware and battery/AC policy qualification | #355 |
| Privacy: Screen Lock | Blank delay, lock enable/delay, lock notifications, USB protection, restrict viewing angle | Idle/lock enable/delay live; notification policy and hardware security integration incomplete | #348, #356 |
| Privacy: Permissions / Data / Security | Location/camera access, app grants, history duration/clear, trash/temp cleanup/age, diagnostics, Thunderbolt grants, device-security report | Toolkit recent-file translation exists; external enforcing services and security controls need qualification | #356, #357 |
| Sound | Output/input/test/profiles/volumes, balance/fade/subwoofer, per-app levels, alert choice | Native PipeWire media controls live; full Settings mixer/profile paths unqualified; sound/bell/amplification gaps | #353 |
| Search | App providers enable/reorder, filesystem/default/bookmark/custom locations | SearchProvider2 settings live; filesystem indexing/location service qualification | #361 |
| Apps | Search/notifications/background/screenshot/wallpaper/sound/camera/mic/location permissions; global shortcuts; file/link handlers; storage/cache; defaults; removable-media autostart | Several portal/launch paths exist; full enforcement and media handling unqualified | #348, #361, #365 |
| Wi-Fi / Network | Airplane, hidden/saved networks, hotspot/share QR; wired MAC/MTU/802.1x; IPv4/6 addresses/routes/DNS/search domains; proxy; VPN/WireGuard peers | NetworkManager-backed; shell connectivity is not full Settings proof | #362 |
| Bluetooth | Enable, airplane/hardware-off states, pairing/device operations | BlueZ/rfkill-backed; physical qualification required | #362 |
| WWAN | SIM/slot, PIN, mobile data/roaming, network/mode, APN, modem details | ModemManager-backed; hardware qualification required | #362 |
| Online Accounts | Add/remove/authenticate, enabled account services | GOA and consumer-app integration; qualification required | #362 |
| Printers | Add/remove/default/details, location/driver/PPD/options, test, jobs/authentication/clear, cleaning/ink/status | CUPS-backed; virtual-printer qualification required | #362 |
| Sharing | Device name, file sharing/address/password, media sharing/folders/networks | hostname and sharing-daemon integration; qualification required | #362 |
| System: Region & Language / Users | User/login-screen language/formats, logout; add/remove/enterprise user, name/password/admin/fingerprint/autologin/parental control | AccountsService/PAM/GDM/locale/fprintd/realmd integration; qualification required; interactive auth gap | #362 |
| System: Date & Time | NTP/manual time/timezone, auto timezone, 12/24h, first day, weekday/date/seconds/week numbers | Clock and calendar preferences have live consumers; G-CAL-PREFS proves live weekday changes, ISO week labels and locale reset; shipped timedate/Geoclue qualification remains required | #359 |
| System: Remote Desktop | Sharing/control, hostname/port/user/password/generation/fingerprint, remote login | Portal keyboard/pointer supported; Desktop Sharing works with grd 51 sideloaded on a Corral VM (real FreeRDP frame, view-only refusal, Remote Control, clipboard both ways, lock/revocation/restart); remote login (RecordVirtual), cursor metadata and touch remain, and the published image ships no grd | #358 |
| System: SSH / About / Updates | SSH switch/login command, device name, OS/build/shell/hardware report, software updates | System services and immutable-image integration; require truthful identity and successful update/rollback qualification | #362 |
| Wacom | Pen mode/handedness/aspect/calibration, output mapping, stylus buttons/pressure, pad keystrokes/test | Tablet protocol and event routing missing | #344 |
| Screenshot UI / native protocols | Selection keys, tab dragging, GTK3 portal parents, version floors, color/effects, explicit sync/DRM lease | Selection keys are qualified on the primary output; multi-monitor selection, compositor cursor alignment and recorded protocol deviations remain | #363, #364 |
Filed capability gaps
Every issue identifies source evidence, affected controls, expected behavior and acceptance. Qualification issues explicitly avoid claiming an external service is absent.
| Issue | Gap |
|---|---|
| #336 | Complete remaining hot-corner RTL, native geometry/scaling, activation and physical/shipped-image qualification |
| #337 | Honor Multitasking workspace, edge-tiling and app-switcher preferences |
| #338 | Implement GNOME 51 session save and restore |
| #339 | Implement Night Light rather than only writing its setting |
| #340 | Implement display modes, refresh rate, rotation, mirroring and output disabling |
| #341 | Implement ICC, HDR and GNOME color management |
| #342 | Implement compositor cursor themes, sizes, shapes and locate-pointer |
| #343 | Honor mouse, touchpad, pointing-stick and trackball settings |
| #344 | Route tablet input and implement GNOME Wacom settings |
| #345 | Implement touchscreens, output mapping and sensor-driven orientation |
| #346 | Honor keyboard input-source policy, Num Lock and custom shortcuts |
| #347 | Complete the GNOME window-manager shortcut and focus policy surface |
| #348 | Honor per-app notification preferences and lock-screen privacy |
| #349 | Implement magnification and on-screen keyboard accessibility |
| #350 | Implement accessibility keyboard and pointer input aids |
| #351 | Honor reduced motion, focus visibility and accessibility-menu preferences |
| #352 | Qualify Orca screen-reader activation and complete spoken shell navigation |
| #353 | Honor visual/audible alerts, sound preferences and overamplification |
| #354 | Implement Wellbeing screen-time recording, limits and break reminders |
| #355 | Implement GNOME 51 brightness interface and qualify power policies |
| #356 | Enforce GNOME privacy device controls and qualify retention/security services |
| #357 | Enforce or explicitly delimit GNOME administrative lockdown policies |
| #358 | Qualify GNOME Settings RDP sharing and remote login end to end |
| #359 | Honor GNOME calendar week numbering and first-day preferences |
| #360 | Complete background placement and dynamic wallpaper compatibility |
| #361 | Qualify Apps permissions, global shortcuts, default handlers and removable media |
| #362 | Qualify service-backed GNOME Settings panels on the shipped Marlin image |
| #363 | Complete GNOME 51 screenshot selection keyboard controls |
| #364 | Close remaining Mutter protocol and native GPU compatibility deviations |
| #365 | Reconcile legacy and app-owned GNOME settings without false parity claims |
| #366 | Support and qualify interactive authentication beyond one password |
GNOME application interoperability
The Settings catalog is not an application acceptance matrix. #397 tracks the 28 apps in the current official GNOME Core catalog; all remain awaiting complete per-app acceptance. Its scope includes principal operations, native/Flatpak launch, file/link handlers, portals and permissions, input/scaling, and lock/restart recovery. It does not replace the broader goal of GNOME app interoperability or cover every Circle/third-party app.
#395 tracks missing typed Mutter ServiceChannel provider paths for the GNOME file chooser and global-shortcuts provider. The current installed GNOME portal/type-1 path does not establish those additional roles. The native VM retains a GlobalShortcutsProvider access-denied warning; this is evidence of the missing provider contract, not proof that every Settings action or application fails. Provider identity and capture authorization must remain distinct when these paths are added.
Qualified evidence retained so far:
- Calendar: GTK job 112397815115 on #381 head
700d7c64dd46c90d4e48b01c6f33c71cc883456dpassed G-CAL-PREFS with visible live changes and reset in the same shell. - Handedness and wake recovery: native VM job 112452858990 on #379 head
2f9fbcae00215e9263fdda20ea4276093ae05f96passed nine guest mouse-button events across false/true/false, then VT/S3, stale-PAM rejection, fresh unlock and fresh keyboard input/client repaint. This uses virtual devices and does not qualify physical touchpads or hotplug. - Screenshot selection keys: merged #377, head
4469da9ce2cdd38e6b53a77e1d9671ff0f02b346, passed GTK job 112463147136: arrows, Ctrl, Alt, Shift and R produced actual captures with accessible geometry and bounded PNG dimensions. Multi-monitor selection and compositor cursor alignment remain open in #363/#342. - The consumed-key-state follow-up #394 and native Wayland wakeup fix #399 are merged. The current GTK/native qualifications above include lock input and wake behavior; broader physical and shipped-image acceptance remains separate.
Existing production acceptance blockers
Lifecycle/suspend/VT/logout qualification remains in #62/#68; same-image performance and enforceable budgets in #73/#315; broader stress and final 24-hour soak in #203; test-strategy/security requirements in #8; physical hardware matrix in #314; release support commitments in #313. The strict native VM lane for merged PR #265 now passes lock repaint, stale successful PAM rejection after S3, fresh unlock, client repaint and painted greeter logout. Current native preview qualification is recorded above with its actual boot/lifecycle counts. The published-nightly lane for #273 previously failed final PAM unlock; the fresh signed package and image must still qualify the actual shipped payload. A negative owned presentation interval remains unresolved in #434; the full 24-hour soak has not completed. Coherent Arch image transactions and image-kernel receipts are pending in #461 / #460. Native preview evidence and passing initial logins do not establish final published-image acceptance.
The six existing switch-windows/cycle-windows/cycle-group bindings are corrected in the key inventory. Deprecated GTK, legacy screensaver and app-owned settings are tracked as ownership/compatibility decisions, not assumed GNOME 51 Settings regressions. GNOME Shell JavaScript extensions remain a separate compatibility difference; advertised Wayland globals do not imply complete behavior.
Acceptance should enumerate dynamic controls on the final shipped image, save per-control changed-behavior and negative-control results with exact source/package/image identities, and restore settings afterward. VM evidence covers virtual devices; GPU, radio, biometrics, touch/tablet and multiple physical monitors require separate evidence.